Why ChatGPT writes generic posts for your business
The CopyForce teamHow we write7 min read
ChatGPT writes generic social media posts when it has only a vague request, not the details that make your business recognisable. Give it a short, useful brief before asking for a post, and it has something real to work with.
Stuck after trying AI once, getting a bland caption, and deciding it isn't for you? You're not alone. The draft often falls flat because the chat doesn't know your customers, what you're selling this week or how you speak to people.
Here's what to put in a prompt, with examples you can adapt for your own business.
Generic posts start with a generic prompt
A request such as “Write an Instagram post for my café” leaves a chatbot to fill in the gaps. It doesn't know what is on your counter, why someone should visit now or what sort of café you run, so it reaches for broad language that could fit almost anywhere.
For a neighbourhood café, that might produce:
Prompt: Write an Instagram post for my café.
Caption:
Start your day with great coffee and delicious food at our cosy café. Visit us today!
There's nothing wrong with the grammar, but there isn't much for a customer to hold on to. It doesn't name who the post is for, a menu item, a reason to come in now, a local detail or a voice that feels like the café.
That means you still have to rewrite nearly every line. A better prompt doesn't need to be long. It just needs to give the draft a job and a few facts only your business can provide.
Tell it who you want to reach
Don't try to describe every possible customer in every prompt. Pick the person this particular post is meant to help, remind or encourage.
A dog groomer could write:
Write a friendly Facebook post for owners of muddy spaniels who need a wash after weekend walks.
That one sentence gives the draft a useful starting point. There is a recognisable customer, a familiar problem and a reason for the post to exist. The result is more likely to mention wet paws, muddy coats and the relief of handing over the bath-time job, rather than saying only that grooming is important.
You can choose a customer by looking at the booking, order or question in front of you. A yoga teacher might write for beginners worried about joining their first class. An independent shop might write for someone trying to find a thoughtful last-minute gift. A plumber might write for a homeowner who has noticed a slow leak under the sink.
The more specific the reader, the easier it is to tell whether the finished post sounds useful.
Add the offer and the detail that makes it yours
Next, say what you are actually offering. Include what is in it, where you work if that matters, and one concrete detail from the business. A detail can be a product, a material, a process, an appointment type or something happening on a particular day.
Here is a fuller prompt for the café:
Prompt: Write a warm Instagram caption for our café. We’re serving cinnamon pear buns this Friday and Saturday only. They’re baked before opening and go well with a flat white. Write for regulars looking for a slow weekend breakfast. Keep it simple and don’t use salesy language.
Caption:
This weekend’s bake is a cinnamon pear bun, fresh from the oven before we open. It’s soft, sticky and made for a flat white and an unhurried breakfast. We’ll have them on the counter Friday and Saturday, while they last.
It is still a draft, not a finished post you have to publish untouched. But it now has a real item, a real time frame and clear details you can check quickly. You may swap a word, add the opening time or trim it to suit the photo.
When you're using AI for social media posts, don't ask it to invent the important facts. Give it the facts, then let it help you shape them into a caption, a few versions or a different angle.
Describe how you want the post to sound
A chatbot won't automatically know whether your business sounds chatty, calm, practical or playful. Tell it in a few plain words, then add anything you avoid.
A plumber's voice note could look like this:
Write in plain, reassuring language. We explain things without talking down to people. Avoid jokes and exclamation marks.
That is enough direction to stop a draft becoming overexcited or full of technical terms a customer doesn't need. You could also add phrases you use often, such as “we'll talk you through it”, or words you never use because they don't sound like you.
Try one of these as a starting point:
- Warm and chatty
- Calm and expert
- Straightforward and practical
- Playful but not silly
- Friendly and brief
Then make it more personal. A florist may use simple, sensory words about colour and scent. A builder may prefer short sentences that explain what will happen next. A ceramics studio may sound thoughtful and quiet. Those choices are part of what makes a post feel like it came from you rather than a template.
Give it something happening this month
Useful content needs a current hook. That might be a seasonal service, a new product, a busy period, a customer question, an event or a deadline in the diary.
For example, a ceramicist could ask:
Write 3 short post ideas for this month. I’m making small stoneware bowls in moss green and clay red, posting orders on Tuesdays, and taking custom gift orders until the middle of the month.
Now the chatbot doesn't have to guess what matters. It can suggest a post about the new colours, a practical reminder about posting days, and an update for people considering a custom gift.
Keep a short monthly note somewhere easy to find. Add what has arrived, what you are making, dates that matter, common questions and anything customers are talking about. When you sit down to write, that note gives you material for several posts instead of one vague request.
If you need more places to look for those hooks, 21 content ideas when you're stuck on what to post can help you turn everyday business details into useful topics.
Use a repeatable brief instead of starting from a blank chat
You don't need to explain your whole business from scratch every time. Save a simple brief and fill in the parts that change for each post.
- My business is: [what you sell]
- My customers are: [who this post is for]
- This post is about: [product, service, question or update]
- The useful detail is: [specific fact]
- It matters now because: [date, season or reason]
- My voice is: [3 words]
- Please write: [format, length and platform]
- Avoid: [words or tone you dislike]
Filling this in is the work. AI can shape and vary what you know, but it can't know this month's priorities, your customers' language or your business personality unless you provide them.
If you'd rather not rebuild that background in every chat, CopyForce can turn a short business brief into content ideas for social posts, newsletters, blogs and video, then let you save, organise and develop the ones you want to use.
Edit the draft before you publish it
Even a well-briefed draft needs your eye. Before publishing, check four things:
- Replace any vague claim with a useful fact.
- Add one detail only your business could say.
- Remove wording you would never use in person.
- Check that the post has one clear point.
For a hair salon, a generic line might say:
Transform your look with our expert stylists.
A more useful edit would be:
Got a fringe appointment next week? Save this: dry shampoo can make your fringe harder to section cleanly, so wash it the night before if you can.
The second version gives a customer a practical tip and sounds like something a salon could genuinely tell them before an appointment. It doesn't try to say everything about the business in one caption.
Write one brief for a post you need this week, ask for 3 versions, then keep the version that sounds most like something you'd actually say.
Written with AI, on a topic chosen and approved by our team. How we write